
Frank Horvat Italian, 28/04/1928-21/10/2020
Printed in 2000.
.
Paper: 40 x 30 cm / 15 3/4 x 11 3/4 in
.
There is a photograph by Frank Horvat, made in Soho, London, 1959. Two figures, close-arms loosely knotted, the world receding behind them. The grain is thick, silver halide and shadow, as if the night itself had settled on their shoulders. One wears spectacles, the other a shirt with sleeves rolled, both caught in a moment that is neither performance nor document, but something in between.
It is tempting to say what this image is “about,” but perhaps it is better to say what it does. It holds us at a distance, and yet draws us in. The embrace is both ordinary and singular: a dance, yes, but also a negotiation of space and feeling. The background dissolves, leaving only the haptic fact of touch, the choreography of two bodies in a room. We sense the camera’s complicity-the way it both participates in and withdraws from the scene. Is this intimacy, or the performance of intimacy? The photograph refuses to decide.
Horvat’s Soho is not the Soho of myth, but the Soho of the momentary: a place where the city’s pulse slows, where strangers become partners for the length of a song. The image is not nostalgic, nor is it simply reportage. It is, instead, an invitation-to look, to wonder, to imagine what came before and after. The graininess, that much-mythologized marker of photographic “authenticity,” here becomes a veil, a limit, a kind of permission for the imagination to enter.
If there is meaning here, it is not fixed. The photograph solicits responses that cannot be reconciled, and perhaps that is its strength. Meaning emerges not from the image alone, but from the tension between what is shown and what is withheld. The camera dramatizes the observed, but the drama remains unresolved.
To write “about” such a photograph is to risk diminishing it. Better, perhaps, to write alongside it, to let the image do its own work, to acknowledge that the richest photographs are those that resist summary, that remain open-like a dance, like a night in Soho, London, 1959.